Q: I've had bad experience with their foundation and mascara
A: i really like their eye shadows because they have a wide variety of colors, blend well and last. i'm not too crazy about their lipsticks, in my experience they don't last too long and constantly smear on my teeth. i would recommend their "plushglass" it lasts longer and isn't sticky like their "lusterglass". p.s. couldn't agree with you more regarding their mascara, it's one of the worst i've ever tried.