Q: which one is better?
A: MAC fluid liner sucks. I recently bought it thinking that it was going to be amazing, well it isn't. It cracks, and peels it doesn't stay on very long and if you have sensitive eyes definetely don't get it, it burns. It burns normal skin on your eyes too. HIP cream liner is amazing, it stays on all day, doesn't move, doesn't run, doesn't burn my eyes, I like the way it feels too. Hope this helps, sweetie! (=